Sustainability and Impact
Impact on Sustainability
Electric vehicles are often seen as the key to sustainable mobility. However, their actual climate footprint depends heavily on how long they are used— and on the emissions generated during production, use and disposal. A well-maintained combustion-engine vehicle that is already on the road and continues to be used or exported can, under certain conditions, be more climate-friendly than an electric vehicle that is already replaced after 150,000 km.
The reason lies in the high emissions generated during production – especially for the battery (Scope 3). If the vehicle is replaced prematurely, this creates additional environmental impact that is not offset by local emission savings.
A meaningful assessment must take emissions into account in line with the GHG Protocol, across all three scopes:
- Scope 1: Direct emissions from operation – e.g. exhaust emissions from combustion engines.
- Scope 2: Indirect emissions from electricity generation – e.g. depending on the energy mix used for charging.
- Scope 3: All other emissions from raw material extraction, production, maintenance, transport and disposal.
Electric vehicles often have higher Scope 3 emissions, especially due to battery manufacturing.
Only when all three scopes are taken into account – from sourcing to recycling – can we assess the actual environmental footprint. Focusing solely on “zero local emissions” is incomplete and potentially misleading.
For this reason, we compare the environmental footprint of combustion-engine vehicles and electric vehicles over their entire life cycle – based on reliable data and studies that we have researched to the best of our knowledge and belief. If you spot errors or outdated sources, we would be glad to receive your feedback at: [email protected].
| Life cycle phase (greenhouse gas scope) | MINI Cooper S (petrol) | MINI Cooper SE (electric, EU mix) |
|---|---|---|
| Scope 3 – Upstream (raw materials, production, logistics) | ||
| Raw materials (body) | 4,500 kg | 4,800 kg |
| Raw materials for batteries | – | 5,000 kg |
| Vehicle production (excl. battery) | 1,500 kg | 1,500 kg |
| Battery production | – | 3,500 kg |
| Transport to the dealer | 300 kg | 300 kg |
| Scope 1 (fuel) / Scope 2 (electricity for the use phase) | ||
| Use phase (200,000 km) | 18,000 kg (Scope 1) | 9,280 kg (Scope 2) |
| Scope 3 – Downstream (service & recycling) | ||
| Maintenance & spare parts | 1,500 kg | 1,200 kg |
| Vehicle recycling credit | –700 kg | –700 kg |
| Battery recycling credit | – | –1,000 kg |
| Total emissions (Scope 1–3) | 25,100 kg | 25,880 kg |
| CO₂ per km | 125.5 g/km | 129.4 g/km |
| Potential for second use | Possible (export) | Not included |
| Break-even compared with combustion engines | – | ~205,000 km |
Life cycle assessment – key findings
The MINI Cooper SE has no exhaust emissions (Scope 1), but has higher emissions from production and battery manufacturing (Scope 3). Thanks to the cleaner EU electricity mix, its total CO₂ footprint is now almost identical to that of the petrol-powered Cooper S.
- Over a distance of 200,000 km, both vehicles produce almost the same emissions.
- If the petrol vehicle is exported and used for longer, its CO₂ footprint per kilometre drops significantly.
- If the electric vehicle is replaced prematurely and the battery is not reused: its environmental advantage is largely lost.
In many non-EU countries, the continued use of electric vehicles is limited by a lack of charging infrastructure. For this reason, used electric vehicles often cannot be exported for a second use and are scrapped prematurely – while petrol vehicles can keep running reliably for many more years.
In addition, combustion engines generally have a longer technical service life. The more frequent replacement of electric vehicles due to their shorter service life leads to higher manufacturing-related emissions, which can outweigh the local benefits of emission-free driving.
From a CO₂ accounting perspective, the longer a vehicle is in operation, the lower its emissions per kilometre. For example, extending use from 200,000 km to 300,000 km can reduce the CO₂ footprint per kilometre by up to 33% – without a single new vehicle having to be built.
This means that maintaining, repairing or exporting an existing car can be more climate-friendly than replacing it with a new one – even an electric vehicle.
Conclusion: Sustainability is not limited to the drivetrain – long-term use, second use and a look at the entire life cycle matter even more.
Note: Calculations are based on the EU electricity mix (290 g CO2/kWh). Green electricity, battery reuse or a significantly higher mileage can change the results.
Sources & references (CO₂ balance over the entire life cycle)
- Raw material extraction (Scope 3 – upstream):
ecoinvent-Datenbank, Öko-Institut 2020, Argonne GREET, Fraunhofer UMSICHT, ICCT, T&E 2022, Circular Energy Storage - Battery production:
Fraunhofer ISI, IVL Swedish Environmental Institute, BMW i3 LCA, Agora Verkehrswende 2020–2023 - Vehicle construction (excl. battery):
ICCT 2021, Audi e-tron LCA, BMW sustainability reports, T&E 2020 - Use phase (Scope 1 & 2):
German UBA (2023): emission factors for fuel and electricity, technical data from BMW, EU electricity mix: 290 g CO₂/kWh (Agora Energiewende, European Commission) - Maintenance and repairs:
ICCT, Transport & Environment (T&E), manufacturer data (BMW, Audi, Renault), UBA fleet reports - End-of-life vehicle disposal and recycling:
Umicore, Northvolt, ReLib UK, Audi LCA, BMW i3 recycling study, Fraunhofer ISI
All figures were estimated conservatively, drawing on values from publicly available studies, environmental reports and recognised LCA sources (2018–2024). Minor regional deviations (e.g. in grid composition or recycling standards) are possible.